Each spring, landscape professionals and homeowners alike embark on the task of pruning palm trees. Unfortunately, most palms either don’t need pruning or are incorrectly pruned (often in the same landscapes by the same offenders that butcher Crape Myrtles). As with Crape Myrtle, poor pruning practices can have detrimental consequences for palms and impact their ability to withstand the Panhandle’s harsh environmental conditions. So, how should you prune, or not prune, your palms to avoid causing more harm than good? Let’s find out together.
When pruning any plant, it’s important to understand its natural form and mimic that as closely as possible in the landscape. If you’ve ever noticed an unpruned Cabbage Palm (Sabal minor), Pindo Palm, Chinese Fan Palm, or any of the Date Palms, a few of the more widely grown species in the Panhandle, you’ll notice they all have full, rounded crowns, with leaves covering all hours of the “clock”. What you will never see in nature are palms with only spear leaves (the growth point of the palm) and a leaf or two flanking them. This look was popularized in the past as a method of “hurricane-proofing” palms and is referred to as a “hurricane cut”. The method’s rationale is that allowing more air flow through the crown increases resilience to strong winds. Unfortunately, the opposite is true, and “hurricane cuts” should be avoided for several reasons:
- Severely pruned palms are more at risk of canopy failure during high-wind events. Data following the 2004 and 2005 hurricane seasons found that palms with “hurricane cuts” were much more likely to have their crowns snapped by hurricane force winds than unpruned or lightly pruned palms. Findings showed that the youngest leaves on severely pruned palms lacked support usually provided by older leaf bases and were at higher risk of breaking.
- Severely pruned palms are at higher risk of freeze damage. While cold damage data is more anecdotal, heavily pruned palm trees seem to be less resistant to freezing temperatures. The reasoning here is similar to wind resistance, young, developing leaves are not fully hardened off and do not have the insulating effect a full crown of mature leaves and leaf bases provides. This leaves them exposed to damage from extreme cold temperatures, especially in the less cold-tolerant palms.
- Severely pruned palms are more susceptible to nutrient deficiencies. Due to the sandy nature of Florida’s soils, most palms in the state (Panhandle included) exist in a perpetual nutrient deficiency, primarily Potassium (K). You can see this in older leaves on palms that are slightly yellow, often with brownish tips. Because K is a mobile nutrient (plants can pull K from older leaves to newer developing leaves), if you prune off all the older, yellowing foliage, you exacerbate the deficiency and can induce a slow decline and eventual death.
- Lightly pruned palms provide habitat for beneficial wildlife. A host of native wildlife (birds, bats, mice, raccoons, possums, snakes, frogs, insects, etc.) use palm leaf material for nest building and some nest in the palm crowns and leaf base “boots” themselves. While some of these organisms are more desirable than others, they all provide services to our native ecosystems and overpruning palms removes a vital resource they require.
Now that you know how not to prune palms, the how to is simple! The only time a landscape palm should be pruned is to remove completely dead leaves and flower/fruit stalks. These serve no purpose aesthetically and there is no evidence that removing them will harm the trees in any way. Additionally, some species of palm, like our native Cabbage Palm, can become weedy if seed stalks are left, and palm fruit is messy in yards, doubly so if they fall on hard surfaces like concrete, house roofs, or vehicles. Apart from that, put down the pruners and enjoy healthier, more resilient palms for years to come.
For more information on pruning palms or any other horticultural topic, contact us at the UF/IFAS Extension Calhoun County office. Happy gardening!
4
